Scientific Reviews

NRAO Interactive Services Modification Request 5 T1 2010

1. Introduction

Complete and test review process and release for outside scientific reviews.

2. Background

3. Requirements

  • Reviewers must be able to only see this cycle's proposals, so "options" on left-hand side should probably be removed for reviewing page.

  • Make Time Recommended and Rating floats.

  • Can we check reviewers against authors at the time of assigning reviewers to proposals ? Obviously reviewers shouldn't be reviewing any proposals on which they are an author.

  • Proposals which don't come through the PST, i.e. Global Proposals which come through Northstar, or latex proposal tools. We'd like to have a way that they can get reviewed through the tool. Here is a "minimal" suggestion from Barry:
    • Allow proposal managers to create a proposal with status 'EXTERNAL' and let them set prop_id and legacy_id.
    • If easy, let them also fill in authors and sources.
    • Let them upload a pdf which is the entire proposal as printed from Northstar or latex proposal tools.
    • This would also need to have referee information (such as category assignment) just like 'SUBMITTED' proposals.

4. Design

Technical lead should provide a brief description of how this will be implemented in the code.

5. Deployment Checklist

Documentation? Systems/hardware/networking things needed for deployment?

6. Test Plan

6.1 Internal Testing

6.2 Sponsor Testing

6.3 Integration/Regression Tests


APPROVED: I acknowledge that my request is fully contained in this MR, and if the Open Sky (or other NIS or PST developers) deliver exactly what I specified, I will be happy.

ACCEPTED: I acknowledge that I have validated the completed code according to the acceptance tests, and I am happy with the results.

Written - - - - -
Checked - - - - -
Approved by Scientific Sponsor - - - - -
Accepted/Delivered by Sponsor - - - - -

  • Use %X% if MR is not complete (will display ALERT!)
  • Use %Y% if MR iscomplete (will display DONE)

Discussion Area

-- DanaBalser - 2010-02-27
Topic revision: r3 - 2010-03-10, MarkClaussen
This site is powered by FoswikiCopyright © by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding NRAO Public Wiki? Send feedback