Assessment and some analysis of IRS mapping of purportedly triggered SF regions

G41.1

Background: position looks okay in this 4.5-8-24 + NVSS image:
g41.i2i4m1.nvss.bgpos.jpg

But there's a lot of emission:
g41-bg.25976576.bcd.wave.jpg

There is especially strong H2 and 17um PAH:
g41-bg.png
This is not untypical in the Galactic plane, but we need to understand the magnitude of the effect.

This is the relative difference i.e. a spectrum of the source, abs(raw - bgsubtracted)*2/(raw+bgsubtracted), for two spots on the source:
g41-bgsubrel.pdrspot.pngg41-bgsubrel.hiispot.png

So the background seems okay. Moving on the the ionized lines, in the north, we don't detect higher ionization lines:
SIV < 1MJy/sr
SIII 18um ~ 60-70
ArIII <~2MJy/sr
ArII ~ 20-30
NeIII <~ 1
NeII ~ 65-70, with <10 contamination from the PAH.

All this puts is completely down in the corner of excitation - the rad field harness is <30kK, and/or U is very low:
morisset.png

Now look at n_e - maybe U = n_photon/n_e is low because n_e is high? Here's the SIII 18/33 map in blue. Its higher in the HII region than in the PDR going from ~0.1 to ~0.3. The ratio bottoms out below ~300cm^-3, so the density is at least that low. However, the ratio bottoms out at a value of 0.45, so the measured ratios are unphysically low. Extinction could cause this, and greater extinction in the PDR/rim could account for lower 18/33 there. The Chair+Tielens extinction curve has A_18 ~0.67, A_33 ~0.33, so if I did the math right we need at least A_V~30 to account for the ratios we see:
g41n.s18 33.jpg

Nondetection of Halpha at 3-5Rayleighs implies an extinction of at least 10 or 15, especially for the SNR. consistent but uninteresting.


What about the south? similar situation, similar numbers: g41s.s18 33.jpg

We do detect SIV in the south, but not obviously in the place that we also have SIII, so that ratio will still be an upper limit:

I think we'll have to adopt an extinction curve and make an extinction correction map for the ionization maps, based on the SIII/SIII map and assuming the low-density limit of that ratio.

There's a lot of diffuse emission in the BG spectra, but the location looks clean, so for now assume its properly removing diffuse galactic emission... there's the problem of extinction again here - if the background is extinguished behind the hii region then the assumption is wrong... pooh.:
g44.34-0.8 bgpos.jpg

This source has lots of H2 emission in lots of lines - it'll take an excitation analysis to see if its radiative or shocked. the SiII spot has SiII and possibly some FeII emission there too, so very excited, whatever the mechanism.:
g44.34-0.8.cont.jpgg44.34-0.8.h2lines.jpg

The second plot in particularshows three H_2 lines, with increasing J_up from R to G to B (I think its S(1),S(2),S(3) I forget since yesterday). Despite the obvious differences in spatial distribution between the lines, so far my fits to the N/g vs E_J diagram yeild about 500K, maybe 400 or so in some places, and a 550K tail in other places, but not obviously changing. this needs more careful analysis, and smaller regions, etc.

the SIII 18/33 ratio is similar numerically to the others - at the low-density limit in the center of the HII region, maybe even above it slightly, and then dropping to zero in the PDR. The RH figure has SIII 33 intensity as the blue, so you can see that the SN is pretty poor outside the HII region, although the ratio does come back up again:

g44.34-0.8.r18_33.jpg g44.34-0.8.r18 33b.jpg
Topic attachments
I Attachment Action Size Date Who Comment
g41-bg.25976576.bcd.wave.jpgjpg g41-bg.25976576.bcd.wave.jpg manage 61 K 2010-12-18 - 08:59 RemyIndebetouw  
g41-bg.pngpng g41-bg.png manage 8 K 2010-12-18 - 09:05 RemyIndebetouw  
g41-bgsubrel.hiispot.pngpng g41-bgsubrel.hiispot.png manage 7 K 2010-12-18 - 09:22 RemyIndebetouw  
g41-bgsubrel.pdrspot.pngpng g41-bgsubrel.pdrspot.png manage 6 K 2010-12-18 - 09:21 RemyIndebetouw  
g41.i2i4m1.nvss.bgpos.jpgjpg g41.i2i4m1.nvss.bgpos.jpg manage 73 K 2010-12-18 - 08:57 RemyIndebetouw  
g41n.s18_33.jpgjpg g41n.s18_33.jpg manage 14 K 2010-12-18 - 13:11 RemyIndebetouw  
g41s.s18_33.jpgjpg g41s.s18_33.jpg manage 16 K 2011-01-03 - 09:51 RemyIndebetouw  
g44.34-0.8.cont.jpgjpg g44.34-0.8.cont.jpg manage 35 K 2011-01-03 - 11:42 RemyIndebetouw  
g44.34-0.8.h2lines.jpgjpg g44.34-0.8.h2lines.jpg manage 18 K 2011-01-03 - 11:42 RemyIndebetouw  
g44.34-0.8.r18_33.jpgjpg g44.34-0.8.r18_33.jpg manage 28 K 2011-01-04 - 10:11 RemyIndebetouw  
g44.34-0.8.r18_33b.jpgjpg g44.34-0.8.r18_33b.jpg manage 30 K 2011-01-04 - 10:11 RemyIndebetouw  
g44.34-0.8_bgpos.jpgjpg g44.34-0.8_bgpos.jpg manage 53 K 2011-01-03 - 11:30 RemyIndebetouw  
morisset.pngpng morisset.png manage 119 K 2010-12-18 - 09:27 RemyIndebetouw  
Topic revision: r9 - 2011-01-05, RemyIndebetouw
This site is powered by FoswikiCopyright © by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding NRAO Public Wiki? Send feedback